Chubby Deli

Chubby Deli, located at 630 Pine Aire Dr in Bay Shore, NY, stands out as a beloved local deli that truly understands how to deliver hearty, satisfying meals with a generous touch. Specializing in classic deli fare with a gourmet twist, this spot is a haven for anyone craving comfort food that’s as abundant in flavor as it is in portion size.

From the moment you step inside, Chubby Deli offers a warm, no-frills atmosphere where the focus is clearly on high-quality ingredients and meticulously prepared dishes. Their gourmet hero sandwiches are nothing short of legendary—especially the famed Chicken Cutlet BLT with mayo on a perfectly toasted roll. Imagine biting into a crisp, golden breaded chicken cutlet layered with smoky bacon, fresh lettuce, and ripe tomato, all elevated by the creamy mayo that brings it all together. These sandwiches are sized generously, with many customers swearing by the foot-long heroes that make for a real feast.

The menu doesn’t stop at sandwiches. Chubby Deli’s hot food buffet is a treasure trove for pasta lovers and chicken enthusiasts alike. Rich, comforting pasta dishes like baked ziti, vegetable lasagna, and rigatoni alla vodka boast just the right balance of savory sauce and perfectly cooked pasta. Chicken entrees, from honey mustard to chicken marsala and chicken parmigiana, highlight their knack for tender, flavorful proteins that never disappoint. One customer describes Mac & Cheese with a chicken cutlet and mashed potatoes as “amazing,” capturing the heartwarming appeal of their homestyle cooking.

Appetizers such as their assorted cheese platters and fresh vegetable platters served with house-made ranch dip add a fresh and sophisticated touch that's perfect for sharing. Meanwhile, the antipasto tray with prosciutto-wrapped breadsticks and a variety of Italian cold cuts offers a glimpse into the deli’s commitment to quality and flavor diversity.

For those who appreciate traditional deli staples, Chubby Deli also offers Kosher-style options like pastrami, corned beef, and turkey sandwiches, complete with classic toppings like cole slaw and fresh tomatoes. These classic selections reflect a deep respect for deli tradition, combined with a modern flair that keeps loyal customers coming back.

Customer testimonials paint a vivid picture of what sets Chubby Deli apart: “They NEVER mess up orders,” raves one satisfied regular, while another gushes about the "feast" they experienced with the bacon, egg, and cheese breakfast sandwich. Portions here are generous, flavors bold, and every dish seems crafted with genuine care. Whether grabbing a quick breakfast or indulging in a filling lunch, guests feel appreciated and thoroughly satisfied.

In summary, Chubby Deli excels as a destination for anyone seeking authentic deli excellence in Bay Shore. The combination of hearty dishes, attentive service, and consistently large portions makes it not just a meal stop but a memorable culinary experience. If you’re looking for a place that serves classic deli favorites with a gourmet touch—and leaves you absolutely delighted—Chubby Deli should be at the top of your list.